Air exchangers are pretty simple boxes inside. Some fans, and a exchanger core, some ductwork in and out. Look primarily at the wattage each one draws, and pick one from the installer you trust the most, who will back up their service. That usually matters more than brand.
We've used Lifebreath to good effect. The Building Science folks are using Fantech predominantly from what I saw at NESEA this year. Venmar has a good reputation here in Maine.
Talking to the Renewaire folks, they swear their ERV is good enough even in the coldest climates, that the core never ices up. David Foley in Northport ME used one in their studio, said it didn't frost up at all last winter:
http://www.nesea.org/blog/2009/03/dear-jamie/