Posted By bmancanfly on 12 Mar 2010 11:21 AM
So you're saying that if I have proper insulation between the ceiling and attic it's not worth adding additional venting to the attic. BTW the attic is not usable space.
That's what I'm saying.
The Florida State Solar Energy Center has studied this one to death. Their best-case scenario real-world testing showed that in an R19 insulated attic a solar powered ventilator could save as much as 6% on the cooling bill. But doubling the R-value to R38 would reap double-digit savings.
Searching their archives for "attic ventilation" yields
this list. Skim a few of those papers. In FL, R30 is fine without ventilation if the solar reflectivity and infrared emissivity of the roof is high enough. If you have a dark roof, R30 at the attic floor with radiant barrier anywhere between the roof deck attic floor and passive venting (like you have) is plenty.
If you have ducts in the attic, insulating the roof deck and sealing the attic has benefits, but it takes a sharp pencil to figure out when/how a retrofit is cost-effective. R19-20 (5.5-6") of half-pound foam on the underside of the roof deck, sealing the vents is pretty common in FL, as is doing it with R12 (2") of 2lb foam (which glues the roof deck & rafters together forming a structural monocoque for hurricane resistance.) But it's not cheap. Blowing 6-8" of cellulose on top of whatever attic floor insulation you have is cheaper, but leaves ducts exposed to the attic heat. Sealing & insulating ducts in an unconditioned attic is usually cost effective.
Attic ventilation is of little value in cooling dominated climates. It's often used for ice-dam control in snow zones