|
|
You are not authorized to post a reply.
|
Prev Next
|
| Author |
Messages |
|
worldwize Registered Users
Posts:1

 |
| 06/09/2007 3:09 AM |
|
hi i was wondering if anyone useing ThermaSteel Panels in any of the work there doing in building a house,if so im real interested in useing it myself for my home .
just let me know how u like it and if there is any tips you can give me on useing it ,and were i can find it.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
tommymac Registered Users
Posts:8

 |
| 06/16/2007 10:33 PM |
|
I love Thermasteel. this is their website
I recently received my third quote from Thermasteel in Roanoke VA. I have been moving very slowly on our project, completely changing designs three times. Mike Meyers, the sales rep, has always been helpful via email. I grew tired of the expense of an architect and his attitude toward SIPS so I purchased the Chief Architect product, transferred my plans in (three months from novice to pretty darn good) and now I email .pdf files of my plans/changes to Kinkos in Blacksburg VA (home of VA tech GO HOIKES!!). Kinkos will print 3'x4' to scale drawings (7 pages) for $35 and Mike picks them up and adjusts my quote.
My quote for 4032 sq ft of 5.5" wall panel, with openings, including screws, base track, corner metal, but not including shipping and taxes is $29,149.38 or roughly $7.23/sq ft of SIP. Is that a good price?
I did receive another quote from a distributor that was 50% higher but included Trade Ready floor joists, something else i like, ttp://www.dietrichindustries.com/traderea.htm so it is not really an apples to apples comparison.
My only dissapointment, and unresolved problem, is the plan calls for a hip roof with living space in what would be the attic. Thermasteel says they cannot quote the roof since it is a hip roof. Anyone have a suggestion?
Our site is heavliy wooded, 85% shade, flat lot and we receive about 40" of rain per year so I am worried about the long term integrity of OSB SIPS. I have not found a suitable builder yet. Anyone out there work in the 22101 zip code?
|
|
|
|
|
mmacgowa Registered Users
Posts:542

 |
| 06/17/2007 11:15 AM |
|
tommymac,
You could virtually have any roof done in SIPs but the price tends to get outrageous considering that your ROI might not be recovered. We quote truss roofs for that reason and for the cutup nature of many roof styles. You can get much of the beneift of seal and R value received from SIPs by using spray foam to seal your roof/ceiling joint and then adding blown in to get a higher R value.
Be careful with products like Home Architect, I have learned the hard way that similar programs do not always give you accurate results. So pay to have a designer or architect review them. Finding out that the icon for a spa tup is not correct or that your roof joist measurments are not accurate are important to know before you break ground.
As for your price, there are probably other factors we would need to know to make a good determination. What is your actual shipping cost? Are you going to get a break on labor? or doing it yourself? Is engineering provided, etc. We also don't know where you live and what you plan to save on your future energy costs. I would consider that on the high side in my area as I use raw panels and can get them on site for less then $3/ft.
OSB SIPs should be fine if you find someone who can build and install flashing but steel may be worth an extra price for piece of mind. At least with OSB wall SIPs and a traditional roof, you might find someone who is willing to build them at a regular stick price. |
|
|
|
|
tommymac Registered Users
Posts:8

 |
| 06/18/2007 12:27 AM |
|
mmacgowa,
My current thought is to use truss framing with sprayin insulation. Blown in on top will not work because there is no space. I will end up with a site built SIP like roof. Meaning under the shingles will be sheathing, under that will be spray in insulation between the trusses, under that will be the drywall finished ceiling. I would like to have a way of not having the sprayed insultion adhear to tightly to the roof sheathing just in case it needs to be replaced someday. |
|
|
|
|
tommymac Registered Users
Posts:8

 |
| 06/18/2007 1:00 AM |
|
mmacgowa,
Answers to some of your other questions.
On Chief Architect. You are right. The software can only do so much and you have to check everything. I have had to build some things using the CAD mode to get the correct dimensions. I find the libraries fairly extensive and you can change the dimensions of any item. I have changed the sizes on all the appliances to match our current selections including clearances. I correctly sized furniture based on things that we like at the stores and placed them on the plan to see how things fit and clearances. Auto building the stairs was fast but then I spent a lot of time changing the rise and run. I hate steep stairs. My wife laid in the electrical plan. She started with the 'auto build' which lays in the wall sockets to code including specing GFI's in the kitchen and baths. You still you have to go room by room and adjust the ones that end up in the door and window trim. She also laid in the can lights based on a free package she got that specs lights based on lumens required for functions in different rooms. It even shows you where to put them in the ceiling. It was time and money well spent. Only dissapointement is the materials list which gives totals for the entire house not by room. Cool part was I built an SIP wall type so it shows how many Sq FT of the stuff I need. It showed the same number as Thermasteel came up with off the printed plan. The plans need to get engineering approval and I can send them in AutoCAD format.
Shipping costs are estimated at $1000 for one flatbed traveling a distance of 270 miles. Do not know about labor costs, not that far along. Not doing it myself. SIP Engineering is included in the price as well as all the openings. I live about ten miles west of the White House. I do not know what I will save in energy costs but the house that is there now is a 1958 rancher with no insulation in the walls, two fireplaces, and the original windows, so I think I will save something.
|
|
|
|
|
ablizz Registered Users
Posts:2

 |
| 09/25/2007 5:22 PM |
|
We too are looking to use Thermasteel panel, although don't quite fully understand the use of it. Do we still need a house frame with thermasteel ? or does it work like panelized home (such as Eaglenest home). We built Eaglenest home, like it , but quite complex to construct. |
|
|
|
|
PanelCrafters Registered Users
Posts:1323


 |
| 09/25/2007 8:28 PM |
|
Posted By ablizz on 09/25/2007 5:22 PM We too are looking to use Thermasteel panel, although don't quite fully understand the use of it. I am wondering how you could consider using a product that you don't understand? Inquiring minds and all of that.
Personally, I would figure out what I'm trying to accomplish and find a product that satisfies the need, instead of trying to force a product into a need that may not be fully defined. |
|
....jc If you're not building with OSB SIPS(or ICF's), why are you building? |
|
|
Alton Registered Users
Posts:308

 |
| 09/25/2007 9:44 PM |
|
JC,
I fully agree that needs should be considered before selecting the product. Too many times I have spent too much time trying to use materials already on hand.
Alton C. Keown Residential Designer and Construction Technology Consultant |
|
Alton C. Keown Residential Designer and Construction Technology Consultant Auburn, Alabama 334 329-0957 AT&T Cellular |
|
|
ablizz Registered Users
Posts:2

 |
| 09/26/2007 5:39 AM |
|
I am a scientist, not a builder. I was GC for our last house, the only house we built (yet); I was just mostly managing and buyer, the subs were experienced folks eager to help a GC gal. We just moved to the coast, and want to build "green" house. Came across Thermasteel, read about it energy saving and so on... Thought some body in this forum may be able to give some tips...
|
|
|
|
|
tmsu Registered Users
Posts:43

 |
| 09/26/2007 8:43 AM |
|
Posted By tommymac on 06/16/2007 10:33 PM
I love Thermasteel. this is their website
I recently received my third quote from Thermasteel in Roanoke VA. I have been moving very slowly on our project, completely changing designs three times. Mike Meyers, the sales rep, has always been helpful via email. I grew tired of the expense of an architect and his attitude toward SIPS so I purchased the Chief Architect product, transferred my plans in (three months from novice to pretty darn good) and now I email .pdf files of my plans/changes to Kinkos in Blacksburg VA (home of VA tech GO HOIKES!!). Kinkos will print 3'x4' to scale drawings (7 pages) for $35 and Mike picks them up and adjusts my quote.
My quote for 4032 sq ft of 5.5" wall panel, with openings, including screws, base track, corner metal, but not including shipping and taxes is $29,149.38 or roughly $7.23/sq ft of SIP. Is that a good price?
I did receive another quote from a distributor that was 50% higher but included Trade Ready floor joists, something else i like, ttp://www.dietrichindustries.com/traderea.htm so it is not really an apples to apples comparison.
My only dissapointment, and unresolved problem, is the plan calls for a hip roof with living space in what would be the attic. Thermasteel says they cannot quote the roof since it is a hip roof. Anyone have a suggestion?
Our site is heavliy wooded, 85% shade, flat lot and we receive about 40" of rain per year so I am worried about the long term integrity of OSB SIPS. I have not found a suitable builder yet. Anyone out there work in the 22101 zip code?
TMac, My OSB SIPs, with a hip roof, cost around $4.50 per square foot. I used 6.5" panels for the walls and 8.5" panels on top of a standard truss system (24"O.C.). This included the engineered plans, holes cut for windows and doors and screws/washers. The panel measurements were spot on and I was surprised how well the roof went together. It wasn't super smooth but that was my fault, not the panel manufacturers fault. A little bit of "carpentry work" made it all good. My roof panels (not the hip part) were 17' x 8'. I used a crane to hoist them into place and then screwed them into the trusses. The pitch of the roof is a 6/12. This gives me a nice large storage area but not really pratical living space. I suppose if I had gone with a steeper pitch, that would change. Anyway, my two cents
Tmsu
|
|
|
|
|
cmkavala Registered Users
Posts:807


 |
| 09/26/2007 9:13 AM |
|
| we build hips all the time with our steel SIPs with no fears of building in heavily wooded conditions |
|
Chris Kavala chris@southernsips.com 1-877-321-SIPS |
|
|
lkazanov2 Registered Users
Posts:110

 |
| 09/26/2007 4:23 PM |
|
Posted By tmsu on 09/26/2007 8:43 AM
Posted By tommymac on 06/16/2007 10:33 PM
I love Thermasteel. this is their website
I recently received my third quote from Thermasteel in Roanoke VA. I have been moving very slowly on our project, completely changing designs three times. Mike Meyers, the sales rep, has always been helpful via email. I grew tired of the expense of an architect and his attitude toward SIPS so I purchased the Chief Architect product, transferred my plans in (three months from novice to pretty darn good) and now I email .pdf files of my plans/changes to Kinkos in Blacksburg VA (home of VA tech GO HOIKES!!). Kinkos will print 3'x4' to scale drawings (7 pages) for $35 and Mike picks them up and adjusts my quote.
My quote for 4032 sq ft of 5.5" wall panel, with openings, including screws, base track, corner metal, but not including shipping and taxes is $29,149.38 or roughly $7.23/sq ft of SIP. Is that a good price?
I did receive another quote from a distributor that was 50% higher but included Trade Ready floor joists, something else i like, ttp://www.dietrichindustries.com/traderea.htm so it is not really an apples to apples comparison.
My only dissapointment, and unresolved problem, is the plan calls for a hip roof with living space in what would be the attic. Thermasteel says they cannot quote the roof since it is a hip roof. Anyone have a suggestion?
Our site is heavliy wooded, 85% shade, flat lot and we receive about 40" of rain per year so I am worried about the long term integrity of OSB SIPS. I have not found a suitable builder yet. Anyone out there work in the 22101 zip code?
TMac, My OSB SIPs, with a hip roof, cost around $4.50 per square foot. I used 6.5" panels for the walls and 8.5" panels on top of a standard truss system (24"O.C.). This included the engineered plans, holes cut for windows and doors and screws/washers. The panel measurements were spot on and I was surprised how well the roof went together. It wasn't super smooth but that was my fault, not the panel manufacturers fault. A little bit of "carpentry work" made it all good. My roof panels (not the hip part) were 17' x 8'. I used a crane to hoist them into place and then screwed them into the trusses. The pitch of the roof is a 6/12. This gives me a nice large storage area but not really pratical living space. I suppose if I had gone with a steeper pitch, that would change. Anyway, my two cents Tmsu TMSU,
Who was your SIP supplier?
Thanks,
Leonard
|
|
|
|
|
gameboy Registered Users
Posts:9

 |
| 09/26/2007 8:22 PM |
|
Thermasteel quoted me over $14.00 a square foot.
Perhaps my project was too complicated, though it sure doesn't seem that way. Needless to say, I am looking elseware. |
|
|
|
|
tmsu Registered Users
Posts:43

 |
| 09/27/2007 1:36 AM |
|
Leonard,
My supplier was PorterSIPs out of Holland, MI. My experience with them was very good. Granted this was my only experience but their quote was quick, thorough and one of the lower ones I received. I was welcomed when I asked to tour their facilities and see the manufacturing process. Nothing fancy but impressive nonetheless. Their engineering department was easy to work with and the panels were built exactly per spec. I know that I am blowing sunshine but with all of the other horror stories I have read, these guys deserve the publicity.
Tmsu |
|
|
|
|
|
| You are not authorized to post a reply. |
|
|
|
ActiveForums 3.6
|
Professionals Serving Your Location:
GBT Project Albums:
|