Posted By riscy on 02/10/2009 12:05 PM
Desuperheater is a useful feature to provide heating for DHW tank, however when I carefully read various document, please correct me if I'm wrong.
(a) Desuperheater only work when GSHP is active, it is not on-demand basis
(b) So the climate need to optimised to ensure GSHP is operating all time.
(c) It has different performance for heating and cooling.
(d) On demands is better using valve switching between DHW and central heating/cooling.
For climate where 70% heating and 30% cooling operation take place, I think desuperheater does not suit.
A. That is correct, a Desuperheat only works when the system is running.
B. You do NOT want the GSHP to run all the time, the desuperheater is only preheating the water so the hot water heater doesn't have to bring cold water all the way up to the hot water you expect when you take a shower, also it's helping to keep the hot water already in the tank hot until needed. You still require a Hot water heater that is either electric or Gas, a Desuperheater alone will not heat your water hot enough. Since your not running the hot water all the time, and the hot water heater isn't running all the time to keep water hot, the GSHP doesn't need to be on all the time.
C. A desuperheater is most efficent when cooling your home, In cooling mode, it's extracting heat from your house and using some of that heat to pre-heat your hot water. In Heating mode, it's basicially robbing the heat pump of some of the heat you need to heat your house, but even with that loss, it's far more efficent to heat your water with a desuperheater than to rely only on the electric water heater element (or Gas).
D. I would say Point of Service On demand water heater are more effiecent. But only POS units, that is a unit for you kitchen sink, a unit for the shower, a unit for the dishwasher, having a unit for every point that requires hot water can be a very costly initial install.
I disagree, a Desuperheater is ideal for any climate.