Posted By jonr on 03 Jun 2013 11:51 AM
If you are taking the drywall off anyway, adding rigid foam underneath the new drywall will outperform refilling the stud bays. And add a well sealed air barrier.
You'd need at least 1.5" of polyiso or 2.5" of EPS for that statement to be true.
Adding that much foam
AND refilling the stud bays would roughly double the whole-wall R.