Posted By lisa6801 on 06/06/2009 9:00 AM
I also see that some insurance /window companies (PELLA)don't like it.
THX LRM
That's because some monster lawsuits have arisen as a result of product and installation deficiencies. Whenever complex technology is used to substitute for simpler systems (usually to reduce cost), quality control becomes critical.
For example; caulking is a complex technology often asked to substitute for the high reliability and longevity of simpler mechanical barriers. However, to be as effective it requires much more skill in application. The problem is that while a poorly applied flashing will often leak in the first rainstorm, it may take years (i.e. outside the warranty period) to discover caulking was inadequate.
The quandary for homeowners (and builders) is ensuring enough oversight at the journeyman level. It is easy to inspect flashing, but almost impossible to inspect caulking.