Questions about ICF Walls and Footers
Last Post 06 Dec 2011 01:51 PM by Alton. 26 Replies.
Printer Friendly
Sort:
PrevPrev NextNext
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 2 of 2 << < 12
Author Messages
AltonUser is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:2158

--
06 Dec 2011 04:47 AM

Bob,

Yes, this North wall will be more like a retaining wall.  If so, then should the wall be sitting in the middle of the footer or nearer the inside of the basement like a true retaining wall?

No worry about heaving from frost in our climate.  No worry about clay soils since we plan to have a 24" wide overcut backfilled with clean gravel.  This 2' wide by 10' gravel should slip and slide enough to relieve stress from any swelling adjoining soil.  It will also allow water to fall to the drain.

I would have more confidence in a 21' tall wall backfilled 10' if it were thicker thicker than 6".  I would also prefer 4000 PSI concrete for the below portion of the wall.  I think the higher PSI concrete properly vibrated would be more dense to water and also be stronger with a tighter bond to the rebar.
Residential Designer &
Construction Technology Consultant -- E-mail: Alton at Auburn dot Edu Use email format with @ and period .
334 826-3979
ICFHybridUser is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:3039

--
06 Dec 2011 09:54 AM
I have an engineered wall that is 23' high in 6" ICF. It has an additional (large) floor on top of that..... Backfill is 10' in clay. Length of unbroken wall is up to 36'.

Mix was 3500 psi with 3/4" max aggregate. Air entrained to 6%

Vert bar is #5 at 16" OC
Horiz bar is #5 at 16" OC
arkie6User is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:1453

--
06 Dec 2011 10:12 AM
Posted By Alton on 06 Dec 2011 04:47 AM

No worry about heaving from frost in our climate.  No worry about clay soils since we plan to have a 24" wide overcut backfilled with clean gravel...
That will significantly reduce the pressure on the wall compared to cohesive clay soil in contact with the wall.

Have you looked at HUD's "PRESCRIPTIVE METHOD FOR INSULATING CONCRETE FORMS IN RESIDENTIAL CONSTRUCTION" Second Edition?  You can find this online if you look around a bit.  I have a pdf copy saved on my hard drive.

As an example, in the above document in Table 3.5 "MINIMUM VERTICAL WALL REINFORCEMENT FOR 7.5-inch- (191-mm-) THICK FLAT ICF BASEMENT WALLS" it shows that for a 10' high wall with 9' of unbalanced backfill height, that #5 GR 40 rebar @ 14" OC is acceptalbe if the maximum equivalent fluid pressure density of the backfill is 30 pcf (typical for the gravel you propose), while #5 GR 40 rebar @ 6" OC is required if the maximum equivalent fluid pressure density of the backfill is 60 pcf (typical for heavy clay).  Note that using GR 60 rebar instead of GR40 allows you to increase the rebar spacing by 1.5 times.


FBBPUser is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:1215

--
06 Dec 2011 10:41 AM
Posted By Alton on 06 Dec 2011 04:47 AM

Bob,

Yes, this North wall will be more like a retaining wall.  If so, then should the wall be sitting in the middle of the footer or nearer the inside of the basement like a true retaining wall?

No worry about heaving from frost in our climate.  No worry about clay soils since we plan to have a 24" wide overcut backfilled with clean gravel.  This 2' wide by 10' gravel should slip and slide enough to relieve stress from any swelling adjoining soil.  It will also allow water to fall to the drain.

I would have more confidence in a 21' tall wall backfilled 10' if it were thicker thicker than 6".  I would also prefer 4000 PSI concrete for the below portion of the wall.  I think the higher PSI concrete properly vibrated would be more dense to water and also be stronger with a tighter bond to the rebar.


Alton - I'm guessing the P.Eng. is going to earn his keep on this one ;-) Heres what I see. If its designed as a retaining wall, the extended footing (i,e, the wall is sitting way to the inside of a wide ftg.) with the bar placed to provide max. strength at the 90º, you might still have a problem in the "clean gravel". If the gravel is what we would call "drainage stone (3/4" to 1.5" washed rock no fines) then the stone can move somewhat at will therefore not providing resistance to overturn. That is when the outer edge of the footer wants to start to lift because of the force applied at the top of the wall the stone will just rattle on down. Each push at top allows a little more lift at the bottom till eventually you have catastrophic failure. Hope this makes sense. Its easier to show with drawings. If the "clean Gravel" can't move, yur back to soil pressure! Also its always interesting to see the difference climate makes. Looking at ICFHybrid's wall I would say "no way." But I have to allow for heavy frost action so maybe without that concern his design is fine but I don't think I would be able to sleep nites with a wall like that! Bob
arkie6User is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:1453

--
06 Dec 2011 11:27 AM
Posted By Alton on 04 Dec 2011 05:41 PM
Arkie6,

...We have considered using Simpson Strong-Tie clips in the ICF wall but prefer a ledge more so for 4x2 floor trusses or TrimJoists.  The Simpson method requires three clips on each end of a truss.

In order to avoid having a brick ledge to the inside, we are considering Dietrich Trade Ready Joists and Steelform joists.  I do not know which steel system will be the least expensive until we get quotes.  At least with the steel joists, all we have to do is attach a steel channel to the East/West walls and then screw the steel joists to the channel.  A brick ledge would not be needed.

If we go with steel joists instead of wood floor trusses, then the question becomes whether to use bolts or ICF clips to hold the c-channel to the side of the wall.  If we use bolts, then it would probably be Red Head Large Diamter Tapcons installed after the concrete has set.
 
What would be your preference?
I don't have any experience with steel joists and have never really looked into them, so I can't provide any input there.

General practice around here is to use wet set or pre-set J type anchor bolts whereever possible due to lower cost, quicker installation (no holes to drill in the concrete), and higher confidence that they won't pull out or crack the concrete if near an edge.

For my home I wanted the ability to run all of my mechanical equipment through the floor system over the basement so I elected to go with open web engineered 4x2 floor trusses.  These are designed and manufactured here local to me so that made the decision easier.  I also looked at the Simpson ICF connectors for holding a ledger board to the walls, but ultimately decided to use 8" walls in the basement with 6" walls on the main floor.  For the cost of the Simpson ICF connectors, I could increase all 4 of my basement walls from 6" to 8" core.  I felt that was better use of my money.

The top of the 8" basement walls have a custom made taper top that I made on the inside and I have a full 2x4 plate secured on top of this concrete ledge with pre-set J type anchor bolts.  The floor trusses are top chord hung and hang from the plate on top of the basement wall.  You may be thinking "how does he get a 3.5" wide ledge to accommodate a 2x4 when the difference in width between the 8" wall and 6" wall is only 2"?  For the 6" wall above the basement wall, I will cut off part of the inside foam to go over the 2x4 plate and double 2x4 top chords of the trusses.  This also allows me to put a 1" strip of foam board on the inside of the wood to keep the concrete from the upper level pour from touching the wood.  See sketch below.

I like the pre-set J type anchor bolts.  I secured mine to the ICF ties with wire every 4' OC and 2" from the inside edge of the ledge prior to the pour.  I put a piece of duct tape over the threads during the pour to keep concrete out of the threads.  After the pour when it came time to set the 2x4 plate, I ran a string line down the top of each wall where I wanted the inside edge of the plate to be.  I then measured from the side of each anchor bolt over to this line and wrote that measurement with a sharpie on the concrete next to the bolt.  I then set the 2x4 plate in its position on edge next to the anchor bolts and marked a vertical line on each side of every anchor bolt to define the bolt hole OC spacing.   I then layed the 2x4 flat and used the measurements previously marked on the concrete +1/4" to determine how far from the edge of the 2x4 to drill my holes (5/8" hole for 1/2" anchor bolts) and used a combination square adjusted accordingly to make my marks.  After drilling the holes, the 2x4 plates dropped in place over the anchor bolts.  If using this method, it doesn't really matter how well aligned your anchor bolts are - the end result is that the wood plate is positioned properly.  I also ran a couple beads of F26 on the concrete prior to setting the treated 2x4 plates to help fill in any voids and help lock them in place.






ICFHybridUser is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:3039

--
06 Dec 2011 11:52 AM
But I have to allow for heavy frost action so maybe without that concern his design is fine but I don't think I would be able to sleep nites with a wall like that! Bob
What is the seismic design category?
AltonUser is Offline
Veteran Member
Veteran Member
Send Private Message
Posts:2158

--
06 Dec 2011 01:51 PM
I have a copy of the building code and I see that my wall exceeds the code - will need engineer.

Bob, I follow what you are saying.  Since the footer will be in a trench that is dug in friable sandstone, should the footer be pinned to the sandstone with grouted rebars.  I think the footer in a trench in the weak sandstone will help somewhat but I would have more confidence if the footer could be grouted to granite or hard limestone.

We are considering using a ductless HVAC system to avoid the extra cost for a plenum under the floor trusses or joists.

I do not know if the area where the house will be built is subject much to earthquakes.  I guess it is time to search the code for the map.

Residential Designer &
Construction Technology Consultant -- E-mail: Alton at Auburn dot Edu Use email format with @ and period .
334 826-3979
You are not authorized to post a reply.
Page 2 of 2 << < 12


Active Forums 4.1
Membership Membership: Latest New User Latest: Julio89 New Today New Today: 0 New Yesterday New Yesterday: 0 User Count Overall: 34737
People Online People Online: Visitors Visitors: 115 Members Members: 0 Total Total: 115
Copyright 2011 by BuildCentral, Inc.   Terms Of Use  Privacy Statement